An Isa Genzken sculpture found itself in a bizarre turn of events last month. First, it appeared on a popular German television program akin to the U.S. series , then was almost immediately put up for auction—before being swiftly yanked from the block.
Two recent German newspaper reports recount the strange incident that occurred on the popular German television show (), where eager candidates bring on artworks and objects to have their value assessed by a panel of experts.
According to , the September 6 episode featured an intensive care nurse identified only as Jörg F., who presented a Genzken sculpture that he said he’d received as a gift from the artist, during a period in which she was battling health issues and he cared for her. The work in question was identified as (2011) and consists of a concrete block with two antennae. Jörg F. reportedly said the work was not to his liking and he wanted to sell it.
Art dealer Detlev Kümmel, who was also on the episode, said that the work could fetch up to €35,000 ($36,700). The show then staged an auction where dealers have the opportunity to bid on the objects that the guests present. Jörg F. ultimately walked away with less than half the estimated amount, $16,800, which came from a jewelry specialist identified as Susanne Steiger.
Neither Kümmel nor Steiger responded to requests for comment.
The next day, the sculpture appeared for sale at Sotheby’s Cologne, with a much higher estimate of €30,000 to €50,000 ($31,500 to $52,550), bearing the provenance of “an important private collection from North Rhine-Westphalia.” According to the Sotheby’s lot description: “This work is registered under the in the archive of works by Isa Genzken, Galerie Buchholz Cologne, Berlin.” Galerie Buchholz did not immediately respond to request for comment.
In yet another twist, at some point before the Sotheby’s auction took place,th sculpture was yanked from the sale—at the behest of Genzken’s lawyer.
A representative for Sotheby’s Cologne confirmed the news, telling Artnet News via email: “Sotheby’s has withdrawn the work in agreement with the consignor, and [can] provide no further detail at this stage. Sotheby’s confirms that the work was not withdrawn on authenticity grounds. The work is signed Isa Genzken and dated 2011.”
pointed out that there are numerous legal concerns about how the nurse came into possession of the sculpture. Genzken could not be reached for comment but has said that she was receiving inpatient psychiatric treatment at the time. “Until the broadcast of the program, this donation was not known, nor was it known that Jörg F. had worked as a carer for the artist and how he came into contact with her. Efforts are currently being made to clarify the matter,” a representative for the artist told . “A lawyer has now been appointed to represent Isa Genzken’s interests.”
The question remains whether the deal between Jorg F. and Steiger could now be negated. posited that the show organizers could have foreseen trouble, adding that people “were too happy to take the supposed joke that a concrete block could be worth so much.”
Jörg F. could not be reached for comment.
According to the Artnet Price Database, a Genzken () dated 1990, sold at Christie’s London in February 2020 for £52,500 ($68,500).