New York City Is Under Fire for Whitewashing a Tunnel Famed for Its Display of Historic Graffiti Art


An ever-evolving graffiti art display in Washington Heights is no more after the New York City Department of Transportation unceremoniously painted over it, sparking community outrage. In response, officials are now promising to work with artists to replace the display in the 1,000-foot-long tunnel famed for its graffiti art.

“We are planning to look for potential artists that will design the 191st Street Tunnel. This is a priority for me because I understand the symbolic meaning behind this cultural mural,” NYC DOT commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez told the local ABC affiliate.

Residents were shocked over the weekend to find that the colorfully painted tunnel had been whitewashed.

“What happened here is just a slap in the face to the community,” local Luiggy Gomez told Gothamist. “They erased history.”

Technically called “Tunnel Street,” the three-block-long passage is the city’s only underground street, according to 6sqft. It serves as a Broadway entrance to the 191st Street subway station, which, at 175 feet underground, is the deepest in the system. It was built to provide an alternative to climbing up Fort George Hill to the other entrance on St. Nicholas Avenue, as the elevators are outside the far zone.

A public art project in 2015 had beautified the tunnel with a suite of five murals selected from 150 applications.

The 191st Street tunnel before and after whitewashing. Photo courtesy of City Council Member Carmen De La Rosa.

The 191st Street tunnel before and after whitewashing. Photo courtesy of City Council Member Carmen De La Rosa.

The artists included longtime New York City graffiti artist Fernando “Cope 2” Carlo Jr., who began tagging the streets back in 1978, with additional works by Nick Kuszyk, Nelson “Cekis” Rivas, Andrea “Queen Andrea” von Bujdoss, and Jessie Unterhalter and Katey Truhn.

Much of that work had since been covered by graffiti tags, but the display was still something of a local landmark. It also featured prominently in the 2021 Lin-Manuel Miranda film, , in a fantasy sequence where Abuela Claudia (Olga Merediz) recalls moving to the U.S. from Cuba in the song “Paciencia y Fe.”

A scene from <em>In the Heights</em> shot in the 191st Street tunnel. ©Likely Story, Endeavor Content, 5000 Broadway Productions, SGS Pictures, Barrio Grrrl!

A scene from shot in the 191st Street tunnel. Photo: © Likely Story, Endeavor Content, 5000 Broadway Productions, SGS Pictures, Barrio Grrrl!

The tunnel was recently the subject of a article decrying the people using drugs in the tunnel, and leaving behind trash and “crude graffiti tags.”

Local City Council member Carmen De La Rosa and Nira E. Leyva-Gutiérrez, executive director of the Northern Manhattan Arts Arts Alliance—which partnered with the DOT on the 2015 murals—issued a joint statement claiming that the community’s calls for improvement to the passageway “never advocated for the soul of the tunnel to be removed in the erasure of the local art that was emblematic of the tunnel.” They are “angered and disappointed,” they added, that the DOT acted without warning or engaging the community.

NYC DOT crews recently cleaned the 191st St tunnel & removed graffiti. We value the importance of public art & this cleaning is the first step towards creating new art with the community. We are committed to keeping the tunnel clean in partnership with @NYPDnews & @NYCSanitation.

— NYC DOT (@NYC_DOT) January 23, 2023

At a DOT press conference in which Rodriguez promised to issue a new “Request for Proposals” for the site this week, new graffiti tags could already be seen on the tunnel’s freshly painted walls.

“We look forward to working closely with the community and local elected officials on a project that celebrates the culture and diversity that makes New York so special,” Vincent Barone DOT’s interim press secretary, told the local NBC affiliate.


More Trending Stories:

An Evicted Princess Is Refusing to Vacate a Roman Villa That’s Home to Caravaggio’s Only Ceiling Mural

The Heir of a German-Jewish Collector Is Suing the Guggenheim for the Return of a Prized Picasso Painting—Or $150 Million

An Extremely Intelligent Lava Lamp: Refik Anadol’s A.I. Art Extravaganza at MoMA Is Fun, Just Don’t Think About It Too Hard

Paleontologists in India Have Hit on an Epic Find: Hundreds of Bowling Ball-Sized Titanosaur Eggs

How the Young, Bold Guts Gallery Is Reshaping the Art Trade to Make it More Equitable for the Next Generation of Artists (and Collectors)

With a Trio of Exhibitions in Paris, Philippe Starck Reflects on the Renewed Enthusiasm for His Radical Designs of the 1980s

17 Art Exhibitions Worth Traveling for in Europe This Year, From a Blowout Survey of Yayoi Kusama’s Inflatables to the Largest Showcase of Vermeer’s Work Yet

An Oil Sketch Found Covered With Bird Droppings in a Farm Shed Is Actually an Early Van Dyck, Now Heading to Auction for $3 Million


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here